The Silent London Poll of 2019: The Winners

Happy new decade Silent Londoners! Let’s kick off the Twenties with a party shall we? A Silent London Poll-Winners’ Party. You know the drill by now, these prizes go to the best of the past year in silent film, as voted for by YOU. With that said, I will starting handing out the gongs immediately

48665638798_95c6f8fe96_c

 

  1. Best DVD/Blu-ray of 2019

This was a very popular winner – the Eureka/Masters of Cinema DVD/Blu release of the magnificent Der Golem was by far your favourite disc of the year. The package comprises a beautiful restoration of the movie, accompanied by a choice of great scores and a feast of insightful extras. An excellent choice. I reviewed this release in more detail in the January 2020 edition of Sight & Sound.

  • Honourable mention: Fragment of an Empire (Flicker Alley)

48665977136_16f1a187b3_o.jpg

 

  1. Best Theatrical Release of 2019

Go, Golem! The expressionist classic was your classic for the best theatrical release of the year, as this sumptuous restoration played several dates around the world. I saw it in NFT1 in the summer and I am not sure I have recovered yet.

Bait-1

  1. Best Modern Silent of 2019

It may not BE silent but it WAS shot silent, as forthcoming screenings with live musical accompaniment are sure to emphasise – Mark Jenkin’s brilliant Cornish drama Bait was your favourite modern silent of the year.

  • Read: My review of Bait
  • Honourable mention: A Shaun the Sheep Movie: Farmageddon, of course!

  1. Best Orchestral Screening of 2019

Hands down, your favourite orchestral experience of the year was the closing gala of this year’s Pordenone Silent Film Festival: Hitchcock’s The Lodger, with the Orchestra San Marco, conducted by Ben Palmer, playing Neil Brand’s exquisite score. Bravo, Mr Brand!

  • Read: Ithankyou Arthur: ‘Avenger: Endgame’
  • Honourable mention: Fragment of an Empire, also at the Pordenone Silent Film Festival, with the Orchestra San Marco, playing the original score by Vladimir Deshevov, conducted by Gunter A Buchwald.
The Phantom of the Moulin Rouge (René Clair, 1925)
The Phantom of the Moulin Rouge (René Clair, 1925)

 

 

  1. Best Screening with a Small Ensemble or Duo of 2019

We may have to settle this one with the toss of a coin. your votes led to a tie between two very worthy winners, in no particular order:

  • The Phantom of the Moulin Rouge, accompanied by Stephen Horne and Elizabeth-Jane Baldry, Phoenix Leicester, British Silent Film Festival
  • Der Golem, accompanied by Harmonie Band at the Curzon, Clevedon
Stephen Horne accompanying Tonka of the Gallows at the San Francisco Silent Film Festival in 2019Stephen Horne accompanying Tonka of the Gallows at the San Francisco Silent Film Festival in 2019
  1. Best Screening with a Single Accompanist of 2019

Congratulations to Stephen Horne, who continues his awe-inspiring prize-winning streak in this poll! His beautiful accompaniment of the heartbreaking Tonka of the Gallows (1922) at both the San Francisco Silent Film Festival and the Phoenix Cinema in London was your favourite solo score of the year.

Honourable mention: the industrious Meg Morley, who won votes for a staggering number of different performances. One to watch – if you didn’t know that already.

Lubitsch book

  1. Best Silent Film Book of 2019

I’m so desperate to read this myself, and now you have given me an extra excuse. Joseph McBride’s How Did Lubitsch Do It? is your silent film book of the year. it just goes to show The Importance of Being Ernst …

  1. Best Festival for Silent Film of 2019

Me? You? In Pordenone in October every year? You don’t say! Once again you voted Le Giornate del Cinema Muto as the best festival for silent film this year. Congratulations to Jay Weissberg and the rest of the incredible Giornate team for this winning streak!

  • Read: my daily dispatches from the festival
  • Honourable mentions: The Hippodrome Silent Film Festival and the San Francisco Silent Film Festival who both had lots of fans in this poll.
  • Plus: A few of you plumped for the BFI Southbank Weimar Season which, in the words of one voter, was “not a festival but it was terrific from first to last”.

Hippodrome Cinema, Bo'ness

  1. Best Venue for Silent Film of 2019

You like your cinemas round, northern and covered in spangles and velvet? I can’t blame you. Your first-placed silent film venue of 2019 was the glamorous Hippodrome in Bo’ness, home to the aforementioned festival, of course.

James Harrison, Rosie Taylor and Peter Walsh of South West Silents
James Harrison, Rosie Taylor and Peter Walsh of South West Silents
  1. Silent Film Hero of 2019

An awesome list of heroes proved that the silent film revolution is very much people-powered. After yet another impressive 12 months of curation and presentation in the west country and beyond, the indefatigable James Harrison and the South West Silents team take home your prize for silent film heroes of 2019 – again!

  • Honourable mentions: Tied in the runner-up positions were the San Francisco Silent Film Festival team, and film programmer Miranda Gower-Qian – what excellent company to be in!
Tonka of the Gallows (1930)
Tonka of the Gallows (1930)
  1. Best Silent Film Discovery of 2019

This may be my favourite category – your list of discoveries is so brilliant and broad-ranging. However, there was a clear winner this year. The sublime Czech silent Tonka of the Gallows (1930) and its truly luminous star Ita Rina.

  1. Read: Farran Smith Nehme on Tonka of the Gallows for Film Comment.
48666119167_49bd0e95ab_o
Der Golem (1920)

12. Best Silent Film Restoration of 2019

Guess what? It’s Der Golem! This 4K, tinted restoration of Paul Wegener’s elevated horror by the Friedrich Wilhelm Murnau Foundation was your favourite of the year, and it’s not hard to see why.

 

Betty Balfour as Tiny Toes in Love, Life and Laughter (1923)
Betty Balfour as Tip Toes in Love, Life and Laughter (1923). Photograph: British Film Institute

Congratulations to the winners, whose accolades are all very well-deserved, and many thanks to to the readers who voted – you made a big difference!

  • Silent London will always be free to all readers. If you enjoy checking in with the site, including reports from silent film festivals, features and reviews, please consider shouting me a coffee on my Ko-Fi page.

2 thoughts on “The Silent London Poll of 2019: The Winners”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s